I Want Baby-Sitting Wages!

By Robert Archer
Columnist EducationNews.org

My wife and I needed a night out the other evening.Dinner, dancing, a movie—whatever; we wanted to do the whole date thing.A quick call to a neighborhood teenager brought good news—yes, she was available Saturday night to serve as the much-needed babysitter for our two young children.We had used her before and knew we could trust her; plus, her rate of four dollars an hour per child seemed pretty reasonable, especially when my sanity was involved.

The dinner was exquisite; the movie was adequate; and, overall, the time spent with my wife was invaluable.The thirty-two dollars I handed to the babysitter at the end of the evening was well spent, and I will certainly use this teenager's services again.

As I turned around after walking her home, I began to think, and an epiphany struck me, an idea that could potentially solve practically all of our nation's educational budget woes: Why not have individual parents pay teachers baby-sitting wages on a daily basis?Sure, the plan may sound insulting to teachers at first (e.g., "Baby-sitting?Hardly!I'm an educator!" said with a highly arrogant tone and a nose in the air.)But hear me out on this one.

First, the calculations: I teach approximately 120 students a day (a number that makes some of my high school comrades jealous since it's a bit low).Because I teach each teenager approximately one hour each, four dollars per student per hour would be $480 a day.For the sake of conservative estimates, however, I will assume that at least ten students a day will be absent for some reason (e.g., skipping, attending a family vacation, coughing up a lung—whatever); therefore, I should bring in about $440 per day.

Now, $440 per day would mean approximately $2200 per week.Now (and some of you are starting to get a little interested), there are 36 school weeks per year, so using those numbers, I would have an annual income of $79,200!With that salary, I wouldn't even be so brash as to ask from the district or the state any extra money for weekend grading and preparation hours or in-service time or collaboration days.I think almost $80,000 per year would take care of those other extra hours spent crafting my professional expertise.

And almost $80,000 per year on baby-sitting wages!To think!To dream!(By the way, are any of my peers insulted now?)

And for those of you with a Masters degree, let's throw in an extra dime per student per hour babysat . . . uh, excuse me . . . educated.Doesn't sound like much, but that thin little dime winds up putting over $88,000 in your pockets per year.Not bad for a silly little dime, eh?

For the parents, the numbers would work out like this: with one child's attending six periods a day, the cost would run only twenty-four dollars per day.Over the course of a 180-day school year, the maximum out-of-pocket expense would come to $4,320 (and let us not forget that most children will not have perfect attendance, thereby making that number a bit lower).

Sure, some minor financial issues may have to be considered: How do we pay the principals, administrative assistants, janitors, nurses, district office personnel, bus drivers, groundskeepers, etc.?How do we pay for books, document projectors, desks, paper, copiers, AV equipment, buildings, etc.?How do we pay for the students whose families fall below the poverty line?

OK, so maybe I haven't thought this brilliant plan all the way through—I admit it.But, those miniscule details aren't my forte anyway; neither are they my point.

The reason I used this babysitting scenario is that I, as a public school teacher, am tired of the public's complaining about teachers' "always complaining about money."Maybe the fact that I'm not getting paid even close to babysitting wages to educate our youth is an eye-opening statistic.Or, maybe my calculations are simply wasted on those who have never tried educating 120+ teenagers per day.

Either way, in order for good teachers to remain teachers and in order for more college students to want to be teachers and, ultimately, in order for our students to receive the best possible education, the issue of money must be addressed, however uncomfortable that topic may be to the taxpayers of this nation.

Robert Archer
English Teacher (13th year)
Presently at Shadle Park High School in Spokane, WA
Email: r_archer3@yahoo.com

Published October 13, 2008


Comments (4)

Jim Fedako
Said this on 10-13-2008 At 11:08 am
<em>"The reason I used this babysitting scenario is that I, as a public school teacher, am tired of the public's complaining about teachers' "always complaining about money."</em>

But you just complained about money ... and I'm tired of it too.

<em>Not bad for a silly little dime, eh?</em> It's only a silly little dime since its not yours -- its mine, and its not silly.

The difference between your income and the sitter's income is that her income is derived from subjective value and the market. Your salary is derived from politics and power.

Join the market and you will receive your marginal value product.

Remember, you are really complaining about the amount of money I want to keep in my pocket. No matte how you rationalize it, that is nothing less than envy.
PM Kunkle
Said this on 10-13-2008 At 11:31 am
Excellent analogy!
Christopher Barr
Said this on 10-13-2008 At 04:35 pm
I agree that teachers should be paid at least what child care workers get for each child. However, I also believe teachers should be paid more than that, as they spend much more time in preparation and evaluation than child care workers.

Additionally, they are held to a higher standard with much more responsibility.

I have always said that Americans do not value teachers as much as other professionals. So, it is no wonder to me that most people do not stay in teaching long.
KJ Terrell
Said this on 10-13-2008 At 05:01 pm
this should wake up people who state that teachers are just overpaid babysitters. I think the educators should be paid what they are worth. Where would the doctors/lawyers/judges etc... be without a teacher!!!! It takes a special person to teach and put in all of the unpaid hours to eudcate kids who don't want to be there in the first place with parents who can't be bothered. Kuddos!
Post a Comment
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Approval Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message: